Provocations: bodies

 

Sitting

As adults, how can we explore our embodied knowledges, to understand something about children’s experiences?

Try our activity: Sitting

Read about the activity in the file below and then press play on the audio when you are ready to begin.

 

Download activity in Word format here.

We would love to hear how our work has connected with your work and experiences

 

 How we have used similar activities so far…

In January 2021, Amanda and Anna delivered a workshop for undergraduate students training to work with children as teachers, teaching assistants, play workers and educational psychologists. After taking part in a similar guided activity, calling our attention to how sitting feels, student participants were invited to share their experiences of sitting.

 
 
Image description: drawing of Amanda sitting, in ‘Position of Child’ by workshop participant.

Image description: drawing of Amanda sitting, in ‘Position of Child’ by workshop participant.

 
 

Participants reflections so far... 

‘Amanda’s experience of her time in school, was interesting for many of us and encouraged us to start looking at things from the child’s perspective. An awareness of our own bodies can help us connect with children’s experiences (Horner,2017). Hence, the session on affective methods helped us become more aware of our bodies- reflecting upon the times we were children at school, and how we would feel when asked to do different things. Reflecting upon my own experiences helped me become more attuned to the children's experiences.’ 

 

‘...Timmons (2016) states that it is ‘odd’ that there is no recognition that children have different body types- particularly developmentally as there is a difference in the development of the bones in every child. Timmons (2016) further argues that as practitioners it is important to reflect on this and think about the child’s body and put ourselves in their position.’ 

 

‘This made me reflect on the way the body is seen in education as very uniform; as thirty different students with varying bodies, heights and of different backgrounds are all expected to sit in the same way, and if they do not, the child is seen as not being complacent, even if it is uncomfortable. In turn, the feelings of children are often forgotten and so too is the fact that their feelings hold significance.’ 

 

 ‘The child's experiences are knitted into school, and the school site is a place where all normalising tendencies as well as the oddities of school live side by side (Van de Pol, 2010). By attuning to these different experiences, it taught me to trust what is felt and not just said, and the importance of reflecting upon my own experiences to help understand the child’s.' 

 See references here.

Image description: notes and images relating to the them of ‘sitting’ posted on a Padlet board by student participants.

Image description: notes and images relating to the them of ‘sitting’ posted on a Padlet board by student participants.

 

Provocations: bodies

 

Sensing Spaces

How might recalling sensory memories of spaces we have known help us to attune to the spaces of school and the experiences of children?

Try our activity: Sensing Spaces

Read about this activity in the file below. You can then download the blank postcard and the images as prompts, when you are ready to begin.

 

Download the activity in Word format here.

Download a blank postcard here. The prompt images are available here.

 
blank postcard .jpeg.jpg
 

We would love to hear how our work has connected with your work and experiences

 

How we have used the Sensing Spaces activity so far…

In January 2021, Becky Shaw and Jo Ray delivered a workshop for undergraduate students training to work with children as teachers, teaching assistants, play workers and educational psychologists, 

 The workshop explored the potentials of thinking about all the senses when trying to understand the experiences of a site (in this case school) and the experiences of other people. 

They invited participants to remember an institutional space in their lives...something in the past or in their present, and to share an impression of that space that they could recall. 

These memories of spaces accumulated give an impression of the kinds of experiences that are perhaps not at the forefront of our considerations when we think of a child’s context in school, and the kinds of things that might influence their experiences. 

 

Reflections from Participants so far 

‘During the session, the activity of sharing school memories really allowed me to tap into my senses and recall lost emotions and feelings of my experiences at school. It triggered my senses and I felt as if I had been taken back in time. For example, I can still remember lazy school mornings, walking into a warm, yellow lit classroom hearing the chittering of chatter around the room; feeling mentally unprepared to start the school day. I also remember sitting on the hard, cold floor in the cafeteria for assembly, my aching legs crossed, and neck angled painfully to look at the tall teacher. All these triggered memories and allowed me to empathise with school children …’ 

  

‘In the beginning of the sessions, I struggled recognising the importance of how alternative features of school such as furniture, textures, smells, the building etc., affects a child’s school experience. However, as the sessions progressed, I found myself relating to the content as it triggered a lot of old school memories. These memories enabled me to realise that the school space and features make an impact on how a child experiences school. 

Overall, the odd project helped me to recognise how small changes can make a big impact on pupil’s school experience. These small changes may come in different forms and reveal itself in different ways.’ 

 

‘the activity of sharing school memories really allowed me to tap into my senses and recall lost emotions and feelings of my experiences at school’

sensing spaces.png

‘it awakened memories of school that were unstructured yet had an impact on me, like how i would lay on these big heater pipes in the hallway and how it would feel comforting like a big hug when i was upset,’ 

 

‘Sensory methods ... give an innovative way to interpret data that would ordinarily be over-looked. In the session we were provided with photos the children had taken as part of the odd project and asked how they made us feel. The images created a sense of discomfort as they reminded me of the dirty places I remember from school, like the hall floor during assembly and the mess of food during lunch., I was reminded of things I see differently now to when I was a child. I recall at the time the things these photos reminded me of would have been commonplace in my day-to-day life whereas now I find the memory of them disgusting. This highlighted to me the importance of working with children in research to perceive things from their point of view rather than my own with an adults bias.’ 

‘I remember a real sense of discomfort....I will never forget my feelings of isolation and loneliness... This activity allowed me to dig deep into sensory memories that i didn’t even know i possessed...' 

 

‘experiences aren’t just understood through conversation and observation...’ 

 

‘smell can make us think back to memories perhaps that were thought to be forgotten, awaken an image lost in our minds. Throughout the seminar, Becky and Jo unlocked this pushed away memories by making students aware of other senses we experience in school that are not just directed through the eyes’ 


Suggested reading for Bodies

Boldt, G. (2020). ‘On Learning to Stay in the Room: Notes from the Classroom and Clinic’. In B. Dernikos, N. Lesko, S.D. McCall and A. Niccolini (2020). Mapping the Affective Turn in Education. Theory, Research, and Pedagogy. London: Routledge. Chapter 16, 229 – 244.

De Antoni, A. and Dumouchel, P., 2017. The Practices of Feeling with the World: Towards an Anthropology of Affect, the Senses and Materiality-Introduction. Japanese Review of Cultural Anthropology18(1), pp.91-98.

Pallasmaa, J. (2013). The eyes of the skin: architecture and the senses. London: Wiley-Blackwell.

Previous
Previous

Provocations: Measures